When it comes to packing quilts or sleeping bags, the right sleeping system can make or break your trip. In recent years, backpacking quilts have gained popularity over traditional sleeping bags due to their lighter weight, greater flexibility, and comfort. However, a common problem among backpackers is whether to buy a stock-off-the-shelf backpacking quilt or invest in a custom quilt that fits their needs. This article examines the differences between these two options, highlighting their pros and cons to help you decide which one would be best for your trip.
What are Backpacking Quilts?
Backpacking quilts are lightweight, insulated sleeping bags. Unlike sleeping bags, they do not have a closed foot box or hood, allowing greater freedom of movement and better ventilation. They are designed to be used with a sleeping pad, which protects the back from the cold ground.
Stock-Off-The-Shelf Packaging Clicks
Stock-off-the-shelf fabrics are pre-made fabrics available from various manufacturers in standard sizes and specifications. They come ready to use and are quicker to find than custom made quilts. Many are sold through retailers and are often available at a significant discount during holiday sales.
Examples of popular Stock Quilts
Advantages of Stock Quilts
- Immediate Availability: You can order and receive these quilts immediately without waiting for custom production times.
- Proven Designs: These quilts have been tested by many users, so their performance and durability are well known.
- Cost effective: Usually less expensive than custom quilts due to mass production.
- Enough variety: Many manufacturers offer a range of sizes, temperature ratings, and features to suit a variety of needs.
- It is refundable: when purchased through a retailer such as REI
Disadvantages of Stock Quilts
- Limited personalization: You are limited to the standard sizes, classification weights, and features offered.
- Eligibility May Not Be Absolute: Standard sizes may not fit your body shape or sleeping style properly, which may affect warmth and comfort.
- Less Control over Things: You may not be able to choose certain fabrics or low quality.
Custom Packing Quilts
Custom quilts are made to order to your exact specifications. Many cottage manufacturers or specialized companies offer options for customization of size, type of insulation and weight, choice of fabric, placement of zippers (if any), and other features.
Examples of custom quilts
- Lighted Revelation Quilt Resource: Extensive customization options, including multiple temperature ratings, fabric types, colors, insert fill power, length, width, and features.
- Underground Bandit Quilt (UGQ): Extensive customization options, including multiple colors and fabric types, temperature ratings, widths, insulation capabilities, and features.
- Warbonnet Diamondback Topquilt: A custom quilt with many options for features and warmth.
- Loco Libre Ghost Pepper Quilt: Many fabrics, sizes, and colors. It is famous for hammocks and ground sleepers.
Benefits of Custom Quilts
- Perfect Fit: You can specify the size that exactly matches your body size and the sleeping position you choose.
- Tailored Insulation: Choose an insulation weight that matches your typical weather conditions and personal comfort level.
- Priority Selection: Choose fabrics based on preference for weight, durability, water resistance, or color.
- Special features: Add or omit features such as draft columns, footer boxes, or attachment systems as needed.
Disadvantages of Custom Quilts
- High Costs: Customization is usually more expensive due to the labor and material intensive process.
- Long Waiting Time: Custom quilts can take several weeks or months to be produced and shipped.
- Needs Research and Decision making: You must know your needs well to identify the right options; mistakes can be expensive.
- Limited Return Policies: Most custom quilts are non-returnable if you don’t like them. You buy it, you own it.
Why Choose One Over The Other?
When to Choose a Stock-Off-The-Shelf Quilt
If you’re new to backpacking quilts or just want a quick and reliable quilt without spending extra money on customization, stock quilts are a great choice. For example:
- If you plan on regular 3-season backpacking and are comfortable with a standard size, the REI Magma 30 Trail Quilt is a solid value and low-risk purchase, as you can return it if it doesn’t work for you.
- If you’re looking for a proven design with less complexity, stock quilts provide simplicity without sacrificing functionality.
When to Choose a Custom Quilt
Custom quilts are perfect if you have specific needs or preferences that off-the-shelf options can’t meet:
- If you have an unusual body size or a sleeping position that requires special dimensions.
- If you often backpack in different climates and want precise control over the weight of the backpack.
- If you are looking for specific fabrics, such as a heavier denier for durability or lighter materials for hiking.
- If you appreciate custom features such as draft columns or unique attachment systems.
For example, a hiker preparing for a long-distance hike like the Appalachian Trail might choose a custom Lighted Equipment quilt with its light-weight materials and weather preferences.
The conclusion
Both stock-off-the-quilt curtains and custom backpacking have their place depending on your priorities. Stock fabrics offer comfort, guaranteed performance, and affordability, while custom-made curtains provide perfect fit, complementary insulation, material choices, and special features. Consider your budget, timeline, body size, general weather conditions, and preferences when deciding which option best suits your backpacking needs.
SectionHiker never accepts payment for gear reviews or editorial submissions. If you shop through affiliate links on our site, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. Help us keep checking and writing unsponsored and independent gear reviews, hiking and backpacking FAQs, and free hiking guides.
